VIXX Plagiarism, Why Is This Not A Controversy Yet?

I was listening to Dean's I'm Not Sorry, but the chorus kept reminding me of some other song, so I thought about it and turns out it's VIXX' Shangri-La. I'll put the links here, the choruses are seriously identical.


https://youtu.be/wzvRxguTPa4

Dean's I'm Not Sorry


https://youtu.be/CYEaI5y7QaM

VIXX' Shangri-La

What's more, not long after VIXX' Shangri-La was released, Dean wrote lyrics saying his song was copied then filmed it and posted it on IG ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
이미지확대보기
This is the content of the lyrics Dean posted on IG.
(T/N: The lyrics are indeed talking about how his song got copied)

Original post: http://m.pann.nate.com/talk/343206509
Post response:
[+215][-116]

ㅇㅇ |2018.08.25 23:03 신고하기
Edit: I researched about it, it's not plagiarism if the harmony and genre are simply similar. The melody needs to be identical over at least 4 words for plagiarism to be identified, the two songs' melody lines are similar, but in order for it to be legally considered as plagiarism there have to be at least 4 words with completely identical melody, and also the chord progression, rhythm, and harmony need to be completely the same as well. But Dean's song and Shangri-La only share 1 word and a half of similar melody, and after that it's totally different. I also considered the songs' overall vibe and the general public's opinion, and not only their vibes are different but the vast majority of the general public also do not consider it plagiarism.
94
12
답글 5 답글쓰기
ㅇㅇ |2018.08.25 22:17 신고하기
Heol???? Dean's song from 1:30 and VIXX song from 0:50 are identical
78
64
답글 16 답글쓰기
ㅇㅇ |2018.08.26 00:31 신고하기
You can't blame only the song's producers. Whoever listens to them would know they're identical, but the fact that VIXX promoted with the song and cluelessly supported plagiarism means that they agreed to it. Even if it's not legally recognized as plagiarism, it's definitely subtle PLAGIARISM. If you only blame the producers for plagiarism controversy then why is Sunmi hated on all the time?
62
85
답글 22 답글쓰기
ㅇㅇ |2018.08.25 22:59 신고하기
It's clearly different from the title, it's produced by Divine Channel. Also because it's not legally recognized yet so it's not a controversy yet, right? Why don't you begin by researching about the standards of accusation before you write?
40
1
답글 0 답글쓰기
ㅇㅇ |2018.08.25 23:53 신고하기
Kids, check the facts first^^ Don't just upvote this then run away ㅠ
36
1
답글 0 답글쓰기
ㅇㅇ |2018.08.26 01:04 신고하기
I PDF-ed this, hey OP did you get hit by VIXX?
26
1
답글 0 답글쓰기
ㅇㅇ |2018.08.26 03:03 신고하기
Judging from the reaction on Twitter, it's so obvious who wrote thisㅎㅎ Let's look at the facts and then discuss.... Aihoo seeing kids who haven't even heard Dean's song going 'OMG how dare you copy Dean oppa's song~~~~' makes me sick
24
3
답글 0 답글쓰기
ㅇㅇ |2018.08.25 22:05 신고하기
Swear what you want, don't feed the trolls
24
37
답글 7 답글쓰기

Nhận xét

Đăng nhận xét

Bài đăng phổ biến từ blog này

Have You Guys Seen Kim Shinyoung Criticize Red Velvet?

Hình ảnh
(T/N: Red Velvet is seriously giving me a hard time -_- I tried to avoid translating stuff about them as much as I could but they keep appearing on Talker's Choice) Since Yeri wrote in her profile that her weakness is the lack of energy The hosts ask when she feels most energetic Then Yeri says this moment is her most energetic state Do you see the hosts' reaction at that answer? Kim Shinyoung shook her head and mouthed "Aigoo", and Lee Sangmin's expressions were not good either Lee Sangmin at the back He said multiple times that even so she would do it (get energized) when she has to in order to defend her, And Kim Shinyoung also said she thought Yeri was the type to pour out her energy at once, in order to shield her. But then someone said "Yes Yeri will do it (be energetic) when she has to" And Yoon Seyoon met eyes with the staff and smirked. Just at a glance you would know that smirk embedded uncomfortable feelings. Taeyeon, w...
Đọc thêm

Anyone Wants To Kick E'Dawn's Ass For Me?

Hình ảnh
In Pentagon, my biases are Wooseok and Yanan. When E'Dawn's dating news broke out, I hated that it harmed the team so I wanted to unstan him. BUT Yanan posted on his personal account that Pentagon is ten, And Kino teared up at a fansign while talking about the time they spent at the dorm as 10 people, I thought about that and and thought Pentagon was really supposed to be 10. And today, The kid who doesn't post anything on SNS often, posted a photo of 10 people and left 10 heart signs. I realize that the members are missing the time they were still 10, and still want to continue with 10 people, so I wished E'Dawn could return to us. Huh. Seriously... Should I just kill him..? How-ever. Today, right on Pentagon's 2-year anniversary! Why did it have to be TODAY!!!! This as*hole and his girlfriend HyunA posted dating photos?^^ Doesn't matter if E'Dawn posted them or HyunA did, seems like they were laughing among themselves w...
Đọc thêm

Yeri's Actions Towards Taeyeon vs. Her Actions Towards Red Velvet

Hình ảnh
(T/N: Translating this because it has one of the highest numbers of upvotes I've ever seen) Firstly, with Taeyeon Especially, in the photos at the airport, ReVel members are also behind, I wonder why ReVel members are walking separately Now, to Red Velvet Threatening to hit 3-years older unnie Joy Wendy was going to give the milk to Yeri, but then their eyes met and she turned stiff. Joy worried that Wendy would be embarrassed so she took the milk and drank it while smiling, after that she handed it to Yeri again, and turned stiff the same way. Explanation for these photos: http://kapannbadpann.blogspot.com/2018/08/what-are-yeri-and-irene-doing-in-revel.html (Explanation: The four of them bought presents for Yeri, but she took a glance at them and said "But this is nothing", the members then said "But it's pretty", subtitle: "But the members worked hard to choose it...") Seulgi: Taking care of Yeri is so hard... Seu...
Đọc thêm